Posted in

Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s Athens Speech: A Critical Appreciation

On October 7th, 2026, at the Sixth U.S.-Greece Strategic Dialogue, Secretary of State Marco Rubio delivered one of the most consequential political speeches I have heard in years, probably decades. As such, it should not be subjected to the inane commentary so characteristic of what goes for political discourse in our benighted age. Rather, it merits serious consideration, even when one has significant disagreements with it.[1]

I’ll begin with the appreciation, noting its importance, intelligence, and inspirational character. There are several features of the speech that demonstrate its importance. First, it most likely is the beginning of Rubio’s bid for the Republican presidential nomination in 2028, although I am not optimistic about his chances in a populist driven party. Second, if followed, it would mark a more reasoned justification and modification of a nationalistic American foreign policy. Its tone is more moderate than President Trump’s and appeals to a common basis within the NATO alliance. Set on the Pnyx where the ancient Athenian assembly or ekklesia met, the Parthenon is in the background. The significance is clear. Rubio is appealing to the cultural heritage of Western civilization.

One cannot imagine President Trump doing that. When he speaks, I imagine a huge image of him in the background reminiscent of Charles Foster Kane, the protagonist in Orson Welles’ movie Citizen Kane. The Secretary of State’s speech is a more positive approach, appealing to a common heritage, not personal charisma. Third, its importance is directly related to its intelligence.

Secretary Rubio and, I’m sure, his writers composed a speech that is structured around the classical heritage, in particular that of ancient Greece, which the United States shares with the European nations. Referring to the Parthenon, he states, “For thousands of years, the civilization that built what stands behind me has captivated the imagination of the Western world.”[2] The United States shares in that heritage. “The history of America, the history of my country, is covered with the fingerprints of antiquity.” In particular, he reminds his listeners that ancient Athens “gave us democracy,” shaping “our ideas of law, of virtue, of citizenship, and republican government.”

This is all standard fare in conservative circles, although delivered much more intelligently than often is the case. However, what comes next surprised and impressed me the most, even though, as I will contend later, it is the most problematic feature of the speech. Secretary Rubio appeals to the Greek ideal of thumos, the passionate characteristic of human nature that drives men and civilizations to greatness. His comments are worth quoting in full.

Here, in Athens, we found the first full realization of all the essential traits that would

come to define the West: fierce individuality and relentless ambition; daring exploration

and invention; a yearning for discovery, for adventure, risk and glory. An insatiable

curiosity about the world and the principles by which it operates, a hunger to know the

mysteries of nature and grasp the secrets of the cosmos. An impatience with the notion of

impossibility, chafing at all boundaries and limits, straining to peer into the depths of the

unknown.

This appeal to ambition, risk, and glory runs counter to the tendency, the strong tendency, of today’s anti-western currents in the West that view it as wholly oppressive. Secretary Rubio openly admits that the drive and ambition of the West seem “cruel” to its disparagers but then uses their approach against them by laying at their feet the West’s current cultural malaise.

The Secretary of State accuses contemporary critics of Western culture with discouraging excellence because of the cost and risk and advocating mediocrity for the sake of comfort and safety.

The ideal of many ideologies in our time has, frankly, become a world of perfect safety,

devoid of risk or failure, with neither the glory of victory nor the shame of defeat. Too

often these days, we build downwards. We design our standards to ensure no one will

lose; we preoccupy ourselves more with the comfort of the worst than the potential of the

best. We hold the most exceptional things among us hostage to the average, the ordinary,

the mediocre.

As a teacher of many years, I have seen this in education. I still remember one of my university education professors warning us to look out for the students striving to succeed. They are emotionally unbalanced, he said. Today we often see a lowering or elimination of standards to prevent failure so that students will feel good about themselves. This misguided approach fails to recognize that success through effort and stiving is what makes us feel good about ourselves. The commitment to success in education also prepares students to act successfully in the world outside of the classroom.

For students to succeed academically they need to be courageous and competent with a healthy dose of humility. Competency means the development of skills necessary for the knowledge of a subject or mastery of a task. I mention humility because in order to learn students must recognize that they don’t know something and that the teacher or parent does.

Success, academic or otherwise, demands courage, the willingness to take risks and experience disappointment and failure. The virtue of courage grows from a desire or hunger to succeed. Such a desire requires effort and perseverance. Such desire is shaped by a vision of what one wants to do and be. And there must be the hope that one can attain the knowledge or skill desired. Such courage must be nurtured by parents and teachers who are committed to the child or student’s welfare to such an extent that they are willing to let their child or student suffer through the often painful process of learning, take risks, suffer failure and be there to help them continue to strive and eventually succeed.

We humans have a natural desire for comfort and safety, but that desire cannot be the primary one if one wants to succeed. And if parents and teachers make comfort and safety the primary goals for their children and students, they will nurture a desire that leads to sloth and, finally, despair and resentment of the successful.

Rubio wants to apply courage and competence to national and international success. Therefore, he issues a call for national renewal and for a nationalist policy. The same denigrators of the Western tradition teach “our children to be ashamed of the countries they would inherit.” He decries the trend that “with every passing year, we seemed to outsource more of our sovereignty, transferring our decisions to global bureaucracies far beyond the reach of our control.”

Although I prefer the term “patriotism” to “nationalism,” Rubio’s call is inspiring. According to him, we are at a crossroads, and the next decade is crucial for the future of the West. “The course we take will determine whether the West maintains its place at the head of the world or resigns itself to a future of atrophy and servitude and decline. We will either choose to act now or lose the choice to act at all.”

The Secretary of State then moves to a defense of the Trump administration’s decision to “choose the unapologetic pursuit of national power.” Once again, the words are inspiring and, in many ways, can be read as a call to national and civilizational revitalization and the pursuit of great accomplishments. He even sees signs that Europe is awakening and may begin to join the United States in this cultural renewal.

Rubio criticizes those who would prioritize the global community over one’s own people. Many religious and secular critics do indeed follow this prioritization and cloak it in terms of justice, peace, and love. Yet, it seems obvious that a government’s chief concern should be for the welfare of the people they represent and rule, and if candidates and commentators really believe that the global community takes precedence, they should state this openly so that the people who elect or support them know that.

There is also a naivete among the more idealistic globalist critics of an American nationalist policy. They seem to believe that other nations do not have their own interests and fail to realize that those nations will pursue their own interests without regard to their effect on the United States. Or, even incredibly, they seem to think that it is permissible for other nations to pursue their self-interests but not for the United States to do the same.

So, in many ways, I admire this speech. Nevertheless, I have my doubts. It sees the classical heritage as more monolithic than it is. That heritage might caution him of the danger of hubris. I suggest that Rubio study the disastrous Athenian invasion of Sicily. One wonders whether the speech’s praise of thumos is so easily woven together with its praise of reason, order, and morality in the Western tradition. One does not have to agree with everything in Nietzsche’s rejection of Socrates’ emphasis on reason in favor of a passionate life to see that there is a real tension between the two strands in the classical heritage.

Much more problematic is a speech that simultaneously issues a call to return to Greek thumos with the claim that the classical heritage “paved the way for the gospel of Jesus Christ to find fertile soil in Europe and flourish into the empire of Christendom. It was the foundation of the riches of Christian theology – of Augustine and Aquinas and the whole tradition of natural law.”

The Secretary of State’s definition and application of thumos to the nation is important. “The thumos, as the ancient Greeks called it – the fire of passion, strength, courage, pride – is the heart of great civilization.  And without it? Without it, nations lose their will to fight, the will to strive, the will to survive.”

I read this appeal for a revival of thumos in the West while I was preparing a lesson on Ephesians 4. I was immediately struck by the marked contrast between Secretary of State Rubio’s commitments and the biblical text. Paul urges the church “to walk in a manner worthy of the calling to which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, eager to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace (Eph. 4:1-3 ESV).”

Relentless ambition, pride, seeking glory, fierce individuality or love, humility, gentleness, and unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. Can these be compatible, let alone the first paving the way for the second?

Now, most likely the Secretary’s speech draws upon Plato’s idea of the tripartite soul in The Republic, Book IV or the famous “Allegory of the Charioteer” in The Phaedrus. In these passages thumos or spirit is the seat of pride and anger, but also of courage and desire for honor. When led by reason, it helps control and channel human appetites.

However, the Scriptures do not believe the passions can be controlled by mere human reason. Indeed, Paul contends that the human mind itself has been corrupted by sin and is an agent used for justifying the passions not for controlling them (Ephesians 2:3; 4:17-19). It is only by a renewal of the mind by the Spirit that man can be transformed, and the transformation envisioned is not of the heroic thumos so destructive and impassioned in Achilles. Rather, it is conformity to the person of Christ who humbled himself for the benefit of others (Philippians 2:3-5).

Nor does the Bible support “chafing at all boundaries and limits.” There are limits due to our finite nature. There are limits given to us by God’s law and person. The path to fulfillment is laid out for us to walk in, not to seek to escape from the path and create our own way.

To be fair, the Scriptures do commend courage, righteous zeal and ambition and striving for excellence. God has given us emotions and volition to empower convictions about the truth to live a certain way. We don’t want to have men without chests to borrow C. S. Lewis’ famous borrowing from Plato in the first chapter of The Abolition of Man.

It is also important to remember that Plato makes an analogy between the tripart human soul ruled by reason and the three levels of society. At the top are the philosopher kings who rule by wisdom. The second level consists of the guardians who protect the city and correspond to thumos in the human soul. The philosopher kings are chosen from among them. Finally, there are the workers who produce goods and are driven by the appetites for physical comforts and material wealth. For a harmoniously functioning society they need to practice the virtue of temperance and accept their position as being ruled by the philosophers and protected by the guardians. Please take note. This is not a model that fits in easily with American democracy.

At the same time, Christian criticisms of the speech must recognize the difficulty of applying Paul’s exhortations to humility, gentleness, and love to the political realm on any level. There is a common illusion among many Christians that democracy, which governs by consent of the governed, avoids the problem of the exercise of power over others. It doesn’t. When we vote, we are not merely exercising a right, we are exercising power. We seek to have a certain view of society enforced by the state over those who disagree with that view of society. Is that humble or gentle?

My point is not that biblical ethics are irrelevant to the political realm. The virtues of humility and love are needed, but their application to the church and to the state is not strictly identical. So, we Christians should not reject out of hand Rubio’s speech as mere anti-Christian paganism.

Nevertheless, the danger of the Secretary of State’s speech is that it only makes a passing reference to the Christian faith. Without the mold of the Christian faith, in the wrong hands (and we all are potentially the wrong hands) his vision for Western civilization and America in particular can sound like a renewed call for building the Tower of Babel. I do not think that is his intention, but a much more extensive consideration of the role of the Christian faith in reshaping the classical heritage of Western civilization is required.

So, my concerns and criticisms are genuine and grave, but I don’t want to end on the critical note but the appreciative one. Secretary of State Rubio’s speech is outstanding. It is an appropriate response to a real sickness of the soul in Western society. It points to a way forward. Its very intelligence creates space for open and reasoned dialogue. In contrast to most of the political ranting that grabs the headlines in this day and age, it invites us to reason together and aspire to something great. Let’s talk more.

 

 

 

[1] The speech can be listened to on YouTube by clicking on this link. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eOv1DpML7I4

[2] All quotations are taken from the text of the speech published by the U.S. Department of State. Here’s the link https://www.state.gov/releases/office-of-the-spokesman/2026/10/secretary-of-state-marco-rubio-remarks/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *